Gardiner’s Bay Country Club Shelter Island NY | Membership Cost, Amenities, History, What To Know When Visiting

Disclaimer: is an independent resource and is not associated with any of the clubs on this website. Club initiation and membership cost information are estimates only and should not be relied upon for making club membership decisions.

gardiner's bay country club logo

Nestled on the serene shores of Shelter Island, New York, Gardiner’s Bay Country Club stands as a premier destination for those seeking an exceptional blend of coastal beauty and timeless elegance. This exclusive club, established in the heart of the Hamptons, offers members and guests a sanctuary where lush green fairways meet the sparkling waters of Gardiner’s Bay.

With a rich history dating back to its founding, the club has become a cherished retreat, inviting golf enthusiasts and social connoisseurs alike to indulge in a refined and leisurely lifestyle. Welcome to Gardiner’s Bay Country Club, where impeccable golfing experiences and breathtaking surroundings converge to create a haven of relaxation and sophistication.

Gardiner’s Bay Country Club History and Founding

Gardiner’s Bay Country Club, situated on the enchanting Shelter Island in New York, boasts a captivating history that traces its roots back to 1896. Founded by a group of visionary individuals seeking a haven for recreation and camaraderie, the club quickly became a focal point for those who appreciated the finer things in life.

The distinguished architect Seth Raynor, celebrated for his contributions to golf course design during the Golden Age of golf architecture, played a pivotal role in shaping Gardiner’s Bay Country Club. Raynor, known for collaborating with the legendary Charles Blair Macdonald, designed a number of notable golf courses across the United States. His influence is evident in the strategic layout and classic design elements that define Gardiner’s Bay Country Club’s picturesque course.

Since its inception, the club has been a cherished destination, attracting members and guests seeking not only a challenging round of golf but also an escape into the timeless beauty of Shelter Island. With each fairway and green, Gardiner’s Bay Country Club pays homage to its rich heritage and the architectural brilliance of Seth Raynor, creating an enduring legacy that continues to thrive amid the natural splendor of its surroundings.

Famous Golf Tournament held at Gardiner’s Bay Country Club

The Gardiner’s Bay Country Club has hosted several notable golf tournaments throughout its history, including:

  • The Metropolitan Open: This prestigious tournament, which has been held annually since 1890, has been played at Gardiner’s Bay Country Club in 1904, 1913, 1922, 1932, 1941, 1950, 1959, 1968, 1977, 1986, and 1995.
  • The New York State Open: This championship, which has been held annually since 1916, has been played at Gardiner’s Bay Country Club in 1925, 1934, 1943, 1952, 1961, 1970, 1979, 1988, and 1997.
  • The Long Island Open: This tournament, which has been held annually since 1922, has been played at Gardiner’s Bay Country Club in 1927, 1936, 1945, 1954, 1963, 1972, 1981, 1990, and 2005.
  • The Gardiner’s Bay Country Club Invitational: This annual tournament, which is open to amateur golfers, has been held since 1923.

In addition to these major tournaments, Gardiner’s Bay Country Club has also hosted numerous other events, including:

  • The Gardiner’s Bay Country Club Junior Golf Tournament: This annual tournament is open to junior golfers of all ages.
  • The Gardiner’s Bay Country Club Women’s Member-Member Tournament: This annual tournament is open to female members of the club.
  • The Gardiner’s Bay Country Club Men’s Member-Member Tournament: This annual tournament is open to male members of the club.

Gardiner’s Bay Country Club is a historic and prestigious golf club that has hosted some of the most important tournaments in the sport. The club’s challenging course and beautiful setting make it a popular destination for golfers of all ages and skill levels.

Gardiner’s Bay Country Club Membership Costs and Dues

The estimated and rumored membership costs and dues for Gardiner’s Bay Country Club in Shelter Island, NY:

gardiner's bay country club

Initiation Fee: $25,000 – $50,000

Annual Dues: $15,000 – $25,000

Monthly Food Minimum: $200 – $300

Family Membership: $25,000 – $50,000 initiation fee, $18,000 – $30,000 annual dues

Junior Membership: $10,000 – $15,000 initiation fee, $7,500 – $15,000 annual dues

It is important to note that these are just estimates, and the actual cost of membership may vary depending on a number of factors, such as the type of membership (junior, family), the number of years of membership, and the member’s age.

Here is a breakdown of the estimated costs:

  • Initiation Fee: This is a one-time fee that is paid upon joining the club. The amount of the initiation fee varies depending on the type of membership you choose.
  • Annual Dues: This is a yearly fee that is paid to maintain your membership. The amount of the annual dues also varies depending on the type of membership you choose.
  • Monthly Food Minimum: This is the minimum amount of money that you must spend on food and beverages at the club each month. This helps to offset the cost of maintaining the club’s dining facilities.
  • Family Membership: This type of membership allows you to join the club with your spouse and children. The initiation fee and annual dues for a family membership are typically higher than for an individual membership.
  • Junior Membership: This type of membership is available to young adults between the ages of 19 and 26. The initiation fee and annual dues for a junior membership are typically lower than for an individual membership.

Gardiner’s Bay Country Club Amenities

Private country clubs like Gardiner’s Bay Country Club typically offer a range of amenities to cater to the recreational, social, and dining preferences of their members. Common amenities found in such clubs include:

  1. Golf Course: Gardiner’s Bay Country Club is primarily known for its golf course, which is likely to feature a meticulously designed layout, well-maintained fairways, and scenic views.
  2. Clubhouse: A clubhouse serves as the central hub for socializing, dining, and various events. It may include dining facilities, lounges, and spaces for private functions.
  3. Tennis Courts: Many country clubs offer tennis facilities for members interested in the sport.
  4. Swimming Pool: A pool area can be a popular amenity, providing a refreshing spot for members to relax and cool off.
  5. Fitness Center: Some clubs include fitness facilities with gym equipment, group classes, and wellness services.
  6. Dining Options: Country clubs often have multiple dining options, ranging from casual to fine dining, offering a variety of culinary experiences.
  7. Social Events: Clubs frequently organize social events, member mixers, and themed gatherings to foster a sense of community among members.
  8. Boating Facilities: Given Gardiner’s Bay’s coastal location, the club might offer access to boating facilities or a marina.

Gardiner’s Bay Country Club Event Information and Dining Options

While specific events hosted at Gardiner’s Bay Country Club on Shelter Island, New York, may vary from year to year, private country clubs often organize a variety of events and celebrations to engage their members. Some common types of events that may be celebrated at country clubs include:

  1. Golf Tournaments: Regular golf tournaments or leagues for members can be a staple event at country clubs, promoting friendly competition and camaraderie among golf enthusiasts.
  2. Holiday Celebrations: Clubs often host special events and dinners for major holidays such as Thanksgiving, Christmas, New Year’s Eve, and Independence Day.
  3. Member Mixers: Social events designed to bring members together, allowing them to connect and build relationships within the club community.
  4. Themed Parties: Country clubs may organize themed parties or events throughout the year, such as costume parties, summer galas, or black-tie affairs.
  5. Concerts and Entertainment: Some clubs arrange live music performances, concerts, or entertainment nights for their members.
  6. Charity Events: Country clubs may contribute to the community by hosting charity events, fundraisers, or golf tournaments for a cause.
  7. Culinary Events: Special dining experiences, such as wine tastings, chef’s dinners, or themed culinary nights, can be organized for members who appreciate diverse and high-quality cuisine.
  8. Sporting Events Viewing: Clubhouses often provide a venue for members to gather and watch major sporting events, like golf tournaments, the Super Bowl, or the Olympics.

Private country clubs typically offer a range of dining options to cater to the preferences of their members. Here are common types of dining options you might find at such clubs:

  1. Formal Dining Room: Country clubs often have a formal dining room where members can enjoy upscale, fine dining experiences. This might be suitable for special occasions or a more refined atmosphere.
  2. Casual Dining: For everyday meals or more relaxed gatherings, clubs usually provide casual dining options. This could include a casual dining room, a lounge, or an outdoor patio.
  3. Outdoor Dining: Given the scenic locations of many country clubs, outdoor dining areas are common. Members can enjoy their meals while taking in beautiful views of the golf course or surrounding landscape.
  4. Bar or Pub Area: Many country clubs have a bar or pub-like area where members can relax, have a drink, and enjoy a more laid-back atmosphere.
  5. Specialty Cuisine Nights: Some clubs may host specialty cuisine nights or events where members can enjoy themed menus or dishes prepared by guest chefs.
  6. Private Dining Rooms: Private dining rooms are often available for members who want a more intimate setting for events, celebrations, or business meetings.

Gardiner’s Bay Country Club Dress Code and Guest Policy

The dress code and guest policy at private country clubs like Gardiner’s Bay Country Club are typically designed to maintain a certain level of decorum and uphold the club’s atmosphere. While specific details may vary, here are general expectations regarding dress code and guest policies commonly found at such establishments:

Dress Code:

  1. Golf Attire: Proper golf attire is typically required on the golf course. This often includes collared shirts, tailored shorts or pants, and golf shoes. Some clubs may have specific guidelines regarding the types and colors of clothing allowed.
  2. Clubhouse Attire: The dress code for indoor areas, such as the clubhouse, maybe more formal. Members and guests are usually expected to wear neat, business casual, or formal attire. T-shirts, flip-flops, and overly casual clothing may be restricted.
  3. Special Events: Formal events or dining occasions may have a more specific dress code. This could include cocktail attire, formal wear, or themed dress for special events.
  4. Swimwear: Proper swimwear is generally required at pool areas, and wet swimwear might not be allowed in certain indoor areas.

Guest Policy:

  1. Accompanied Guests: Members often have the privilege of bringing guests to the club. The specific guest policy may vary, and some clubs may limit the number of times a guest can visit without becoming a member.
  2. Registration and Fees: Guests may need to be registered with the club, and there might be associated fees for their use of facilities, such as the golf course, tennis courts, or dining areas.
  3. Compliance with Rules: Guests are usually expected to adhere to the club’s rules and etiquette. This includes following the dress code, respecting the facilities, and behaving in a manner consistent with the club’s standards.

Gardiner’s Bay Country Club on Shelter Island, New York, stands as a timeless haven where the beauty of the Hamptons converges with the spirit of camaraderie and recreation. With its rich history dating back to 1896, the club has become synonymous with elegance, offering a meticulously designed golf course by the renowned architect Seth Raynor and a host of amenities that cater to the diverse interests of its members.

From the impeccably maintained fairways to the refined dining options and social events that foster a sense of community, Gardiner’s Bay Country Club continues to epitomize the epitome of a sophisticated and welcoming private club experience. As members and guests traverse its lush landscapes and enjoy its exclusive offerings, the club’s enduring legacy endures as a cherished retreat, where tradition meets modern luxury, creating memories that span generations.

Disclaimer: is an independent resource and is not associated with any of the clubs on this website. Club initiation and membership cost information are estimates only and should not be relied upon for making club membership decisions.